Why are two women to witness alongside one man?
Answer
This verse provides rulings for a specific field of transactions between people, namely the documentation of debts. The stipulation that witnesses in this situation can either be two males, or one male with two females, is partially explained in the verse itself, but scholars have various views concerning the context and wisdom behind this.
In a traditional society where women’s primary task is as a homemaker and mother, it is natural that women would have less involvement with business dealings and financial transactions than men and thus be less likely to be precise witnesses in such matters. It is also possible that the reference to “forgetting” or “straying” here is based on what the Creator knows about the various types of rational and emotional intelligence in human beings.
It is crucial to understand that this verse does not impugn women in either their intellect or character, but provides guidance which believers trust to be for the best, whether they understand the higher reasons or not. It is significant that the testimony of one female alone is accepted in various other matters, and a male witness is deemed unreliable in some areas specific to the life of women. Moreover, all scholars accept females as narrators of hadith provided they are reliable, making no distinction in this regard between male and female narrators.
Summary
This verse indicates that women’s testimony is not equal to men’s in financial matters; this does not impugn their intellect or character, as the Creator knows best the wisdom behind such stipulations.
References